Prose Supplements - Shop now
Kindle Unlimited
Unlimited reading. Over 4 million titles. Learn more
OR
$3.99 with 80 percent savings
Print List Price: $19.99

These promotions will be applied to this item:

Some promotions may be combined; others are not eligible to be combined with other offers. For details, please see the Terms & Conditions associated with these promotions.

Audiobook Price: $21.83

Save: $14.34 (66%)

You've subscribed to ! We will preorder your items within 24 hours of when they become available. When new books are released, we'll charge your default payment method for the lowest price available during the pre-order period.
Update your device or payment method, cancel individual pre-orders or your subscription at
Your Memberships & Subscriptions
Kindle app logo image

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.

Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.

Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.

QR code to download the Kindle App

Follow the author

Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.

Creatures of Chaos Kindle Edition

4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars 414 ratings

For a limited time, all orders and KU downloads will receive a ♥ SPECIAL EDITION EBOOK ♥ at no additional cost, which includes full-color digital imagery, character portraits, and exclusive content!

Perfect for fans of forbidden love, high-stakes games, and everything supernatural. Creatures of Chaos is a fast-paced urban fantasy series that’s being called The Serpent and the Wings of Night meets Crave.

--------------------------------------

Chaos, the vicious supernatural competition where heroes are born and riches are won.

To most, it's just an urban legend whispered in the darkest shadows, but that all changes when my best friend drags me into a savage world where vampires, shifters, and fae compete for glory and fame.

As a creature without magic, I’d be a fool to enter Chaos, but the prize—a dagger of untold power—could change my powerless existence. With that dagger, I could wield magic, earn respect, and maybe, just maybe, win the heart of the dragon heir… it’s a risk I have to take.

Now, I'm pitted against beasts in a ruthless battle with no powers, no plan, and an infuriatingly attractive ally who’s just as likely to slit my neck as save it. Every round of Chaos leads me closer to seizing my deepest desires or losing everything.

In Chaos, survival is the only rule. And winning is all that matters.

Due to its large file size, this book may take longer to download

Customers also bought or read

Loading...
Popular Highlights in this book

From the Publisher

Creatures of Chaos

Ensley - Creatures of Chaos

Locklyn - Creatures of Chaos

Becks - Creatures of Chaos

Talon - Creatures of Chaos

There's only one rule in Chaos: win or die trying.
Julie Hall

Editorial Reviews

About the Author

Julie Hall is a USA Today bestselling, multiple award-winning author.She writes YA paranormal / fantasy novels, loves doodles, and drinks Red Bull, but not necessarily in that order. Julie's daughter says that her super power is sleeping all day and writing all night... and well, she wouldn't be wrong. Julie currently lives in Colorado with her four favorite people - her husband, daughter, and two fur babies. Website: www.JulieHallAuthor.com Newsletter: http: //bit.ly/JulieNL BookBub: http: //bit.ly/JulieBB Fan Club: http: //bit.ly/JulieGroup Instagram: http: //bit.ly/Juliegram

Product details

  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0CRQHSRCS
  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ Julie Hall LLC (October 29, 2024)
  • Publication date ‏ : ‎ October 29, 2024
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • File size ‏ : ‎ 10.5 MB
  • Simultaneous device usage ‏ : ‎ Unlimited
  • Text-to-Speech ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • Screen Reader ‏ : ‎ Supported
  • Enhanced typesetting ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • X-Ray ‏ : ‎ Not Enabled
  • Word Wise ‏ : ‎ Not Enabled
  • Print length ‏ : ‎ 445 pages
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars 414 ratings

About the author

Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.
Julie Hall
Brief content visible, double tap to read full content.
Full content visible, double tap to read brief content.

Julie Hall is a USA Today bestselling, multiple award-winning author.

She writes YA paranormal / fantasy novels, loves doodles, and drinks Red Bull, but not necessarily in that order. Julie's daughter says that her super power is sleeping all day and writing all night... and well, she wouldn't be wrong.

Julie currently lives in Colorado with her four favorite people - her husband, daughter, and two fur babies.

Website: www.JulieHallAuthor.com

Newsletter: http://bit.ly/JulieNL

BookBub: http://bit.ly/JulieBB

Fan Club: http://bit.ly/JulieGroup

Instagram: http://bit.ly/Juliegram

Customer reviews

4.6 out of 5 stars
414 global ratings

Review this product

Share your thoughts with other customers

Customers say

Customers find the story engaging and fast-paced. They appreciate the brilliant, strong characters and their development. The book is described as an exciting and fun adventure with thrilling action and high-stakes trials. Readers enjoy the good balance of fantasy and romance in the story. They describe the love triangle as engaging and sweet. Overall, customers consider the book a worthwhile read with its hidden details and beautiful cover.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

31 customers mention "Story quality"28 positive3 negative

Customers enjoyed the engaging story and love triangle. They found the book fast-paced with many twists and turns. Readers also enjoyed the introduction of a new world and the strong characters.

"...I was captivated from the very first chapter. I loved the fast-paced plot, loveable characters, thrilling action, and high-stakes trials...." Read more

"...But buckle up because this whole fast-paced story leads directly into an ending that will leave you begging for more the moment it's finished...." Read more

"Great plot line and story...." Read more

"...I loved the characters and the whole storyline...." Read more

13 customers mention "Character development"13 positive0 negative

Customers enjoy the character development. They find the characters brilliant and strong, even without magic.

"...I enjoyed Locklyn's character development, determination, and resilience. And holy-cliffhanger! I need book 2 stat!..." Read more

"...I loved the characters and the whole storyline...." Read more

"...The author has created an amazing world with relatable characters and I cannot wait to read more!..." Read more

"...I absolutely loved Locklyn and all the supporting characters!!..." Read more

10 customers mention "Fun ride"10 positive0 negative

Customers enjoy the book's engaging plot, loveable characters, thrilling action, and high-stakes trials. They describe it as an exciting fast-paced paranormal fantasy that hooks them from the start.

"...I loved the fast-paced plot, loveable characters, thrilling action, and high-stakes trials...." Read more

"...If you've made it this far, well done! Just go get the book, it's so much fun, and that's what I needed in my life at the moment." Read more

"...been nice amd more character development but all in all this was a fun read and also one of the most beautiful special editions of any book I’ve seen..." Read more

"...Either way, it was a great time and I was hooked from page 1. I cannot wait until the next book comes out!!" Read more

6 customers mention "Fantasy content"6 positive0 negative

Customers enjoy the fantasy content of the book. They find it an engaging read for young people who enjoy fantasy. The book is described as action-packed and romantic, with original games in the plot.

"...packed, fast paced, electrifying romantasy that will capture your imagination and your heart!..." Read more

"...The games are so originally written in this plot, a tournament or games are often found in YA books, but Julie includes them in a very unique way..." Read more

"...I was happy to see that this book did a good job of balancing the fantasy and romance...." Read more

"...Great read for young people who enjoy fantasy and for those of us who enjoy stories without spice. Thanks again Julie" Read more

6 customers mention "Romance"6 positive0 negative

Customers enjoy the romance in the book. They mention it's a best-friends-to-lovers story with a love triangle. The main character, Locklyn, wants to be the perfect match for her childhood crush. The book balances fantasy and romance well.

"...Even though Becks is a sweet friend and finally comes to his senses, I'm fully #TeamTalon lol. Talon recognized Locklyn's worth from the start...." Read more

"...is so different and I love that Locklyn isn’t just this amazing super chick who succeeds at everything she does and is supernaturally gifted or..." Read more

"...This series starter has it all. Hot guys? Check. Best friends. Double check. Crazy love triangle? Triple check. Want to know my vote? No?..." Read more

"...And the LOVE TRIANGLEEE. This is best-friends-to-lovers but also a love triangle with the tall, dark, mysterious newbie that comes in wanting this..." Read more

5 customers mention "Edge detail"5 positive0 negative

Customers like the book's edge detail. They mention the hidden artwork on the page edges when you fan the pages, and the gold edges on the cover.

"...Signed, color art, foiled hardcover, HIDDEN edges, and even comes with a cute bag and stickers! I am in love with this book!..." Read more

"I buy a lot of books but this one tops most of them! The details in edges, reversible jacket and the overall quality is superb...." Read more

"...on the chapter pages and throughout the book, the special hidden artwork on the page edges when you fan the pages, the green ribbon book mark, even..." Read more

"...The hidden pictures in the edges is the coolest thing. So glad I talked myself into getting this book." Read more

5 customers mention "Love triangle"5 positive0 negative

Customers enjoy the love triangle in the book. They find it engaging.

"...about the relationships in this book, the found family vibes, the love triangle, and the tension are absolutely amazing...." Read more

"...Hot guys? Check. Best friends. Double check. Crazy love triangle? Triple check. Want to know my vote? No?..." Read more

"...And the LOVE TRIANGLEEE. This is best-friends-to-lovers but also a love triangle with the tall, dark, mysterious newbie that comes in wanting this..." Read more

"...you’d want in a fantasy- fae, shifters, magic, deadly trials, love triangle!..." Read more

5 customers mention "Value for money"5 positive0 negative

Customers appreciate the book's value for money. They say it's worth every penny and comes in a beautiful black velvety cover.

"...P.S. the special edition is stunning and definitely worth the price!" Read more

"...Absolutely worth every penny! Also in a beautiful black velvety book bad! You won’t be disappointed." Read more

"...It does end on a cliffhanger but it soooooo worth it." Read more

"...book yet, but this deluxe edition is absolutely gorgeous and well worth the price! Love that it's signed and came with swag from the author...." Read more

Gorgeous book! Amazing story! 100% worth it!
5 out of 5 stars
Gorgeous book! Amazing story! 100% worth it!
First of all, this book is GORGEOUS! It literally has all of the customizations I want in a special edition. Signed, color art, foiled hardcover, HIDDEN edges, and even comes with a cute bag and stickers! I am in love with this book! Ok now for the actual content review 😂👇“It’s not magic that makes the creature powerful, it’s the strength of their character and the depth of their soul, and you, Freckles, are the most powerful creature I’ve ever met.”In a world full of supernatural creatures, Locklyn is one of the only beings to have not manifested powers. Being best friends with one of the most powerful dragon shifters and his sister, Locklyn feels weak and less than everyone around her. Not to mention, she wants to be seen as more than a friend to Becks, the dragon she's been pining for. Locklyn has the opportunity to win a deadly magical competition that would grant her the powers to be worthy enough for the dragon heir. However, she enters the competition without her friends beside her and makes a friend in the mysterious newcomer, Talon. Needless to say, there comes to be a bit of a love triangle between Locklyn, Becks and Talon. Becks doesn't realize how much he desires Locklyn until Talon shows an interest in her. I’m normally not a fan of love triangles, but this one was done really well. Even though Becks is a sweet friend and finally comes to his senses, I'm fully #TeamTalon lol. Talon recognized Locklyn's worth from the start. I'm also supremely curious about the secrets he's still hiding.As with all of Julie Hall's writing, I devoured this book! I was captivated from the very first chapter. I loved the fast-paced plot, loveable characters, thrilling action, and high-stakes trials. I enjoyed Locklyn's character development, determination, and resilience. And holy-cliffhanger! I need book 2 stat!If you love YA fantasy romance and the tropes below, check out this book!Tropes:✨️forbidden romance✨️fake dating✨️love triangle✨️secret dating✨️deadly competition✨️underdog FMC✨️fae and magic✨️vampires and shifters✨️high stakesOther favorite quotes:“You’d be a fool to change one thing about yourself. You’re already perfect.”“It’s not that I just don’t like seeing you in someone else’s arms, it’s that it’s agony for me to see you there when I know there’s no one else’s arms you should be in but mine.”
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

  • Reviewed in the United States on October 30, 2024
    First of all, this book is GORGEOUS! It literally has all of the customizations I want in a special edition. Signed, color art, foiled hardcover, HIDDEN edges, and even comes with a cute bag and stickers! I am in love with this book! Ok now for the actual content review 😂👇

    “It’s not magic that makes the creature powerful, it’s the strength of their character and the depth of their soul, and you, Freckles, are the most powerful creature I’ve ever met.”

    In a world full of supernatural creatures, Locklyn is one of the only beings to have not manifested powers. Being best friends with one of the most powerful dragon shifters and his sister, Locklyn feels weak and less than everyone around her. Not to mention, she wants to be seen as more than a friend to Becks, the dragon she's been pining for. Locklyn has the opportunity to win a deadly magical competition that would grant her the powers to be worthy enough for the dragon heir. However, she enters the competition without her friends beside her and makes a friend in the mysterious newcomer, Talon. Needless to say, there comes to be a bit of a love triangle between Locklyn, Becks and Talon. Becks doesn't realize how much he desires Locklyn until Talon shows an interest in her. I’m normally not a fan of love triangles, but this one was done really well. Even though Becks is a sweet friend and finally comes to his senses, I'm fully #TeamTalon lol. Talon recognized Locklyn's worth from the start. I'm also supremely curious about the secrets he's still hiding.

    As with all of Julie Hall's writing, I devoured this book! I was captivated from the very first chapter. I loved the fast-paced plot, loveable characters, thrilling action, and high-stakes trials. I enjoyed Locklyn's character development, determination, and resilience. And holy-cliffhanger! I need book 2 stat!

    If you love YA fantasy romance and the tropes below, check out this book!

    Tropes:
    ✨️forbidden romance
    ✨️fake dating
    ✨️love triangle
    ✨️secret dating
    ✨️deadly competition
    ✨️underdog FMC
    ✨️fae and magic
    ✨️vampires and shifters
    ✨️high stakes

    Other favorite quotes:
    “You’d be a fool to change one thing about yourself. You’re already perfect.”

    “It’s not that I just don’t like seeing you in someone else’s arms, it’s that it’s agony for me to see you there when I know there’s no one else’s arms you should be in but mine.”
    Customer image
    5.0 out of 5 stars
    Gorgeous book! Amazing story! 100% worth it!

    Reviewed in the United States on October 30, 2024
    First of all, this book is GORGEOUS! It literally has all of the customizations I want in a special edition. Signed, color art, foiled hardcover, HIDDEN edges, and even comes with a cute bag and stickers! I am in love with this book! Ok now for the actual content review 😂👇

    “It’s not magic that makes the creature powerful, it’s the strength of their character and the depth of their soul, and you, Freckles, are the most powerful creature I’ve ever met.”

    In a world full of supernatural creatures, Locklyn is one of the only beings to have not manifested powers. Being best friends with one of the most powerful dragon shifters and his sister, Locklyn feels weak and less than everyone around her. Not to mention, she wants to be seen as more than a friend to Becks, the dragon she's been pining for. Locklyn has the opportunity to win a deadly magical competition that would grant her the powers to be worthy enough for the dragon heir. However, she enters the competition without her friends beside her and makes a friend in the mysterious newcomer, Talon. Needless to say, there comes to be a bit of a love triangle between Locklyn, Becks and Talon. Becks doesn't realize how much he desires Locklyn until Talon shows an interest in her. I’m normally not a fan of love triangles, but this one was done really well. Even though Becks is a sweet friend and finally comes to his senses, I'm fully #TeamTalon lol. Talon recognized Locklyn's worth from the start. I'm also supremely curious about the secrets he's still hiding.

    As with all of Julie Hall's writing, I devoured this book! I was captivated from the very first chapter. I loved the fast-paced plot, loveable characters, thrilling action, and high-stakes trials. I enjoyed Locklyn's character development, determination, and resilience. And holy-cliffhanger! I need book 2 stat!

    If you love YA fantasy romance and the tropes below, check out this book!

    Tropes:
    ✨️forbidden romance
    ✨️fake dating
    ✨️love triangle
    ✨️secret dating
    ✨️deadly competition
    ✨️underdog FMC
    ✨️fae and magic
    ✨️vampires and shifters
    ✨️high stakes

    Other favorite quotes:
    “You’d be a fool to change one thing about yourself. You’re already perfect.”

    “It’s not that I just don’t like seeing you in someone else’s arms, it’s that it’s agony for me to see you there when I know there’s no one else’s arms you should be in but mine.”
    Images in this review
    Customer imageCustomer imageCustomer imageCustomer imageCustomer imageCustomer image
    3 people found this helpful
    Report
  • Reviewed in the United States on October 30, 2024
    I haven't been able to read a book in months. I've been burnt out and steeped in family tragedy. But that changed when I received an advanced audio review copy of this book. It was exactly what I needed!

    From the first page this book MOVES. The characters are hard at work furthering the plot with each new chapter. It flows smoothly from one event to the next which, inadvertently, kept me listening way past my bedtime. I kept telling myself, "Just one more chapter...". The next day I would reward myself with another chapter for completing trivial household tasks lol! (Oh good, I switched the laundry, time for my reward chapter!)

    I have many things I love about Julie Hall's books, but one of the top 3 is her ability to give us an ensemble cast that takes on life as if they're your real friends sitting next to you. They feel complicated and fun and people you would want to go on an adventure with. People you want by your side.

    I'm a sucker for trials and competitions and games, and this book delivers on a silver platter. The stakes just keep getting higher and higher and the twists are deliciously deceptive. Not to mention our main girl, Locklyn, has the very serious problem of two polar opposite dudes tugging her attention string. I'm definitely not mad about it. And the banter. Obsessed. I'm a sarcastic, snarky human when I'm having fun and these characters have lines that make me laugh right out loud!

    I love Julie's attention to the surroundings and the way she describes each new event. She's quickly vivid, helping you map out the important locations in the book so you're never lost. I'm almost never an Urban Fantasy type of reader, but somehow Julie always knocks it outta the park. She's maybe 1 of like, 5 authors I can read Urban Fantasy from and never ever get bored.

    But buckle up because this whole fast-paced story leads directly into an ending that will leave you begging for more the moment it's finished. It's the set up to something absolutely brilliant and you're going to need to find a friend to talk to the moment it's finished. Like, go buddy read this thing so you're not alone. Trust me.

    OH! The freaking narrator! Amanda Lee Cobb has my whole heart and soul! She's a wizard and I think I could listen to her read my minivan's owner manual. I cannot recommend the audio version enough! But like, get that shelf trophy because it has more bells and whistles on it than your last Kickstarter book, hands down. I'm not even joking. If my kids even look at my physical copy I'm going to ground them until they're 47.

    If you've made it this far, well done! Just go get the book, it's so much fun, and that's what I needed in my life at the moment.
  • Reviewed in the United States on November 1, 2024
    Great plot line and story. More world building would have been nice amd more character development but all in all this was a fun read and also one of the most beautiful special editions of any book I’ve seen. Would recommend for anyone into hunger games and magical creatures. Well done. Would recommend
    One person found this helpful
    Report

Top reviews from other countries

  • Susan Macfarlane
    5.0 out of 5 stars Favourite book this year!
    Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 22, 2024
    The moment I read the blurb for Creatures of Chaos I knew I’d love it, but that is an understatement! I’m completely OBSESSED with this one and devoured it in 24 hours.

    I was immediately captivated by the plot and world building and my heart raced alongside Locklyn’s as she faced each one of the Chaos trials, armed only with her wits, fighting skills and the help of the mysterious Talon. The story was fast paced and addictive and the characters were engaging and relatable. Despite her lack of powers, Locklyn was a complete warrior who used her tenacity and mental and physical strength to best her magically powerful opponents. I love a triumph of the underdog story and I was rooting for Locklyn as she faced down each hurdle thrown her way, never backing down. She was loyal to the core and would do anything to help her friends. Even when it meant putting herself or her heart in danger.
     
    There’s a delicious love triangle in the form of two opposite, but equally hot love interests: Becks, Locklyn’s protective childhood best friend and the heir to the dragon throne, and Talon, the dark haired mysterious newcomer who becomes Locklyn’s ally in the Chaos trials. Locklyn’s chemistry with each guy was tangible and butterfly inducing, and I kept secretly hoping that the book would turn into a ‘why choose’ romance! Whilst I’m not adverse to spicy books, I really enjoyed the sweetness of this one and I can’t wait to share it with my daughter who has just got into romantasy books and keeps asking to read mine!
     
    The trials themselves were imaginative and so well written that my heart was in my throat the whole time. I cared so much about Locklyn and I was terrified for her! Without giving anything away, there’s a huge plot twist that I didn’t see coming, and we’re left hanging off a cliff at the end! I need book 2 now!
     
    Packed full of magical creatures, sizzling romance, high stakes and a deliciously twisty plot, Creatures of Chaos is a must read for fantasy fans!
    Customer image
    Susan Macfarlane
    5.0 out of 5 stars
    Favourite book this year!

    Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 22, 2024
    The moment I read the blurb for Creatures of Chaos I knew I’d love it, but that is an understatement! I’m completely OBSESSED with this one and devoured it in 24 hours.

    I was immediately captivated by the plot and world building and my heart raced alongside Locklyn’s as she faced each one of the Chaos trials, armed only with her wits, fighting skills and the help of the mysterious Talon. The story was fast paced and addictive and the characters were engaging and relatable. Despite her lack of powers, Locklyn was a complete warrior who used her tenacity and mental and physical strength to best her magically powerful opponents. I love a triumph of the underdog story and I was rooting for Locklyn as she faced down each hurdle thrown her way, never backing down. She was loyal to the core and would do anything to help her friends. Even when it meant putting herself or her heart in danger.
     
    There’s a delicious love triangle in the form of two opposite, but equally hot love interests: Becks, Locklyn’s protective childhood best friend and the heir to the dragon throne, and Talon, the dark haired mysterious newcomer who becomes Locklyn’s ally in the Chaos trials. Locklyn’s chemistry with each guy was tangible and butterfly inducing, and I kept secretly hoping that the book would turn into a ‘why choose’ romance! Whilst I’m not adverse to spicy books, I really enjoyed the sweetness of this one and I can’t wait to share it with my daughter who has just got into romantasy books and keeps asking to read mine!
     
    The trials themselves were imaginative and so well written that my heart was in my throat the whole time. I cared so much about Locklyn and I was terrified for her! Without giving anything away, there’s a huge plot twist that I didn’t see coming, and we’re left hanging off a cliff at the end! I need book 2 now!
     
    Packed full of magical creatures, sizzling romance, high stakes and a deliciously twisty plot, Creatures of Chaos is a must read for fantasy fans!
    Images in this review
    Customer image
  • Kindle Customer
    5.0 out of 5 stars A gripping story till the end
    Reviewed in India on November 10, 2024
    Wonderful storyline, terrific attack scenes, unexpected villain
    What a beautiful combination for the start of this series.

    Waiting for the second book to jump into their world.
    I love Talon with lock more than Becks with locklyn
    I adore her parents and their love for her
  • Kath
    5.0 out of 5 stars Should be good
    Reviewed in Australia on January 15, 2025
    Haven’t read this book yet but I am sure it will be interesting
    Customer image
    Kath
    5.0 out of 5 stars
    Should be good

    Reviewed in Australia on January 15, 2025
    Haven’t read this book yet but I am sure it will be interesting
    Images in this review
    Customer image
  • Jenny's reviews
    5.0 out of 5 stars A great start to a new series
    Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 6, 2024
    This is a great read and what is a great start to the series. The author is a story teller for sure and weaves a magical world that you can step right in too. The characters are fun and engaging as well as captivating, yet they also have character flaws that make them realistic and relateable. If you are a Fantasy fan this series is definitely for you. My only downfall..... I have t wait for book 2 to come out.
  • Aoife
    5.0 out of 5 stars Definitely recommend reading!
    Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 2, 2024
    "I'm a fighter. It's time I acted like it again."

    This book started off strong and never let up! I was hooked from the start and could barely put it down. I absolutely loved Locklyn. Her strength and vulnerability were just beautifully explored. I need the next book, that cliffhanger had me screaming!
    Customer image
    Aoife
    5.0 out of 5 stars
    Definitely recommend reading!

    Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 2, 2024
    "I'm a fighter. It's time I acted like it again."

    This book started off strong and never let up! I was hooked from the start and could barely put it down. I absolutely loved Locklyn. Her strength and vulnerability were just beautifully explored. I need the next book, that cliffhanger had me screaming!
    Images in this review
    Customer image

Report an issue


Does this item contain inappropriate content?
Do you believe that this item violates a copyright?
Does this item contain quality or formatting issues?