These promotions will be applied to this item:
Some promotions may be combined; others are not eligible to be combined with other offers. For details, please see the Terms & Conditions associated with these promotions.
Your Memberships & Subscriptions

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the author
OK
Hard Twisted: A Novel Kindle Edition
C. Joseph Greaves weaves a chilling tale of survival and redemption, encompassing iconic landscapes, historic figures, America's last Indian uprising, and one of the most celebrated criminal trials of the Public Enemy era, all rooted in the intensely personal story of a young girl's coming of age in a world as cruel as it is beautiful.
Editorial Reviews
From Booklist
Review
“A kind of Dust Bowl Lolita... A gritty, gripping read.” ―Los Angeles Times
“[A] compelling novel…Readers can't help but open their hearts to Lottie. …Her story with all its gritty details and twists deserves wide readership.” ―Library Journal, starred review
“Impressive…a strong literary voice who can render period with authority and violence without sensationalism.” ―Publishers Weekly
“A superb first novel, based on a true story . . . Extraordinarily moving reading.” ―The Guardian
“A masterful literary fiction debut based on the true story of Lucile Garrett... Greaves' understated writing captures the dry, raw-boned beauty of the land and reproduces the distinctive dialect of that time and place with a pitch-perfect ear . . . Comparisons to Cormac McCarthy, another writer of unflinching Western stories, feel apt. In its historical weight and narrative power, Hard Twisted is as epic as the rugged mesas and range its characters inhabit.” ―High Country News
“Greaves is the sort of formidable storyteller and mean prose-stylist that makes it look easy. With all the grit, suspense, pathos, and thrills you could ever ask for in a crime novel, Hard Twisted will leave you in knots.” ―Jonathan Evison, author of West of Here and The Revised Fundamentals of Caregiving
“Standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Mailer, Capote and Berendt, Greaves has crafted a McCarthy-esque non-fiction novelisation that is, at once, both timeless and classic. A truly extraordinary accomplishment, and a wonderful, wonderful book. I was left speechless.” ―RJ Ellory, author of A Quiet Belief in Angels
“Hard Twisted reads like the perfect amalgam of Cormac McCarthy and Jim Thompson: violent, hilarious, and as bracing and painful as the blow of a dog quirt across the face. Utterly irresistible.” ―Pinckney Benedict, Author of Dogs of God, The Wrecking Yard, Town Smokes, and Miracle Boy and Other Stories
“Hard Twisted is fictional crime, with an exceptional true story as its spine, written in a superbly innovative way. Greaves has penned a remarkably fine novel in prose as stylish and engaging as one will find among the most popular authors in this genre. This compelling saga of murder, mystery, and good and evil at its rawest in the hardscrabble rural Southwest of the 1930s should capture and fascinate a wide readership.” ―Vincent Bugliosi, New York Times-bestselling author of Helter Skelter
“Lottie's narration, a mix of naïvete and hard-won toughness, is heartbreaking in its plainspoken recounting of the facts behind a nightmare, but all the characters, even Palmer--a sociopath to his core--reveal flickerings of inner lives that confound our attempts to pigeonhole this seemingly archetypal Depression tragedy. ” ―Booklist
“The true events behind the John's Canyon Murder and the subsequent "skeleton murder trial" of the Depression Era are brought to spellbinding light in Hard Twisted, set in a landscape as brutal as it is beautiful.” ―TheBigThrill
“The fact that this is based on a true story adds to its chilling suspense. Greaves impressively brings alive Lottie's year with Palmer; it felt as real to me as my own childhood…. Hard Twisted grabbed me and didn't let go. It feels like a classic because of Greaves's stylish writing, because of the story's drama, and because of the powerful theme--how Lottie's believable, determined innocence and faith kept her whole. Although Hard Twisted will never be shelved with inspirational books, it inspired me. It's a real-life morality tale, no preaching needed. Recommended.” ―HistoricalNovelSociety
About the Author
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
HARD TWISTED
A NovelBy C. Joseph GreavesBLOOMSBURY PRESS
Copyright © 2012 Charles J. GreavesAll right reserved.
ISBN: 978-1-60819-855-9
Chapter One
A ROOSTER AIN'T NO JOBTHE COURT: Back on the record in Case No. 7421/6150. All jurors are present and the defendant is present. Mr. Pharr?
BY MR. PHARR: Thank you, Your Honor. The People call Lottie Lucile Garrett.
(THE WITNESS, LUCILE GARRETT, IS DULY SWORN.)
BY MR. PHARR: Now, Miss Garrett, you understand that you're under oath, do you not?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: And therefore required to tell the truth?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: Now then, would you please tell the gentlemen of the jury how it was that you first came to meet Clint Palmer?
A: Well, we was camped out on the Gay Road—
BY MR. HARTWELL: Objection, Your Honor. At this time we would renew our motion regarding the testimony of this witness.
THE COURT: All right. I suppose there's no avoiding this. Henry?
BY MR. PHARR: Miss Garrett, were you ever married to the accused?
BY MR. HARTWELL: Objection. Calls for a conclusion. Lay opinion also.
THE COURT: Overruled. You may answer.
A: No, sir. I ain't never been married to nobody.
(PROCEEDINGS INTERRUPTED.)
THE COURT: Order. We'll have none of this. One more outburst and I'll clear the courtroom. Henry?
BY MR. PHARR: You never went through any kind of wedding ceremony with the accused?
A: No, sir.
Q: He never gave you a ring?
A: No, sir.
Q: You never stood up before a preacher?
A: Never did. Never would, neither.
(PROCEEDINGS INTERRUPTED.)
THE COURT: Order. Do not test me.
BY MR. PHARR: Submitted, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Very well. Does counsel wish to voir dire?
BY MR. HARTWELL: Thank you, Your Honor. Isn't it true that you and Mr. Palmer cohabited together over a period of several months during the years 1934 and 1935?
A: Did what?
Q: Cohabited. Lived under the same roof.
A: Well. There weren't no roof to speak of.
(PROCEEDINGS INTERRUPTED.)
THE COURT: Order. Not another peep, I warn you. And the witness will answer counsel's questions without gratuitous exposition.
BY MR. HARTWELL: You lived together as man and wife.
BY MR. PHARR: Objection.
THE COURT: Sustained.
BY MR. HARTWELL: You shared a bed? Or a bedroll?
A: It weren't never my idea.
Q: But isn't it true that you held yourselves out to the public as man and wife?
A: That's a lie. I never done no such thing.
Q: In Monticello, state of Utah, on December the thirty-first of 1934—
BY MR. PHARR: Objection. This is too much, Your Honor. I would remind the court—
THE COURT: All right, all right. That's enough, both of you. I can see where this is heading. The defense motion is denied.
BY MR. HARTWELL: But, Your Honor—
THE COURT: For Christ sake, L.D., these men got crops planted. I said motion denied.
BY MR. HARTWELL: Exception.
THE COURT: Noted. Henry, you may proceed.
BY MR. PHARR: Thank you, Your Honor. Miss Garrett, I think we were by the side of a road somewhere.
They followed the Frisco tracks with their bodies bent and hooded, the pebbling wind audible on the back of her father's old mackinaw. To the west, a line of T-poles stretched to a dim infinity before a setting sun that melted and bled and blended its sanguinary light with the red dirt and with the red dust that rose up like hell's flame in towering streaks and whorls to forge together earth and sky.
Great deal on land! her father called over his shoulder. Bring your own jar!
They came out to the highway and paused there before turning west, the windblown dust in spectral fingers reaching across the blacktop before them. First one car passed without stopping, then another.
You gettin hungry?
No, sir.
The next vehicle that passed was a slat-sided Ford truck that slowed and shimmied and veered crazily onto the shoulder, and as they hurried to meet it, she saw through the swirling grit the crates of pinewood and twist-wire stacked beneath its flapping canvas tarpaulin.
Her father worked the latches and lowered the endgate and vaulted into the truckbed. She reached a blind hand for him and felt herself rising, weightless in a grip as hard as knotted apple-wood, his mangled finger biting into the soft flesh of her wrist.
A bonging sound on the cab roof riled the chickens, and a voice called out from the lowered window, Get on up front, you dumb Okies!
The man looked across her lap and studied her father's shoes. He said his name was Palmer, and that he was a Texan, and a cowboy. He wore sharp sideburns and a clean Resistol hat cocked forward over pallid eyes gone violet in the fading glow of sunset, and she could see that he was small—perhaps no taller than she—and that something fiercely defiant, something feral, was in his smallness.
You get a gander at them gamecocks? the man asked without taking his eyes from the roadway.
Look like right fine birds, her father allowed.
The man chuckled. Mister, them's the gamest fightin roosters this side of the Red, for your information.
That a fact.
Damn right that's a fact. The man nodded once. Damn right it is. You know fightin birds?
Her father did not respond, and the man leaned forward to study his profile before dropping his eyes first to her sweater and then to her lap, returning at last and again to her father's shoes.
How long you been outside, cousin?
How's that?
The stranger's smile was sudden, and unnaturally brilliant, and hot on the side of her neck.
So that's how it is.
Do I know you? her father asked, leaning now to face the man.
Maybe you do and maybe you don't, the man said, his ghost reflection grinning in the darkened windscreen. But I surely do know you.
They'd built a fire in the lee of the ruined house, and her father squatted before it stirring red flannel hash with a spoon. The temperature had dropped with the sun and she wore his mackinaw now like a mantle while he sat his heels and rubbed his hands and warmed them over the skillet, the tumbled walls around them shifting and changing, moving inward and then outward again as though breathing in the soft orange glow like a living thing.
Embers popped, running and skittering with the wind. To the north she saw other fires speckling the void, and she studied their positions as an astronomer might chart the nighttime heavens.
More to night, she said.
Her father followed her gaze. These is hard times, honey. Ain't nobody hirin. Least not in Hugo, anyways. I was thinkin I might light a shuck for Durant come sunrise. Man said a mill there was lookin for hands. Miz Upchurch could mind you for a day.
I don't need no mindin.
He paused and studied her burnished profile, her cheek and lashes luminous in the fireglow.
Tell you what then. You can mind Miz Upchurch. Haul her water and such. You tell her I'll be back by nightfall.
She wielded a broken twig, tracing random patterns in the dirt. Somewhere beyond the firelight, a car passed on the highway.
Who was that man?
Just a man.
He said he knowed you.
He didn't mean like that. More like my kind is what he meant.
What's your kind?
Her father stirred the skillet, and paused, and stirred it again. He tapped the spoon on the iron rim.
Only the good Lord knows what's in a man's heart, Lottie. Happy is the man who follows not the counsel of the wicked nor walks in the way of sinners. He wiped his nose with his wrist. That there's from Psalms.
She poked her stick into the fire and withdrew it and blew out the flame. Then she wrote a secret in the air, and studied it, and watched it disappear in the ravenous wind.
The sun was two fingers off the horizon by the time she awoke. The wind had stilled and the sky had hardened to a diamond blue the weight of which lay upon her in her blankets like some vast and shoreless ocean.
She turned, shielding her eyes with a hand. The white ash of a kindling fire warmed the coffeepot beside her father's bedroll.
She sat up yawning, and then rose to gather some yellowed newsprint from their cache before heading to the creekbed. On her return to the campsite she bent and snapped an aloe spine, spreading the sticky unguent onto her blistered ankle the way the Choctaws did, then she tiptoed back to the fire. There she brushed her hair in long, mea sured strokes, staring out to the north where the night fires had been, but where nothing now stirred.
Among her father's things she found his small leather Bible, and she sat in the shade of the broken house and read from Exodus about the command to the midwives until, setting the book aside, she closed her eyes and touched the slender cross at her throat, praying aloud, Dear Lord, first for her mother's eternal soul, and then for her uncle Mack, and lastly for a Little Buttercup doll with the blue ruffle dress and the matching bonnet with genuine lace trim, her head bowed as she spoke the words, her voice a tin voice in the still and wilted air.
A vulture kited overhead, its shadow rippling darkly over the ground, over the house, over the day.
Over her life.
She replaced the book and stood and stretched again before walking into the sunlight, where she shook the grit from her socks and boots and pulled them on and walked a tentative circle. Then she sat and removed the one boot, folding a strip of newsprint into her sock and replacing the boot and walking another circle.
She hadn't gone but a hundred yards toward the Upchurch farm when she caught sight of the truck. It was parked beside the highway, and the man was standing behind it like an exclamation point after a shouted command.
She looked to the farm house, small yet on the horizon, and back again to the truck.
He was leaning on the fender, the heel of one boot resting in the crook of the other. The sun was to his back, and his hat flapped listlessly against his thigh. He followed her approach until she'd reached the edge of the bar ditch, where she stopped and studied with lowered eyes what ever grew within.
What's the matter, I'm too ugly to look at?
You ain't ugly.
The man worked a matchstick in the corner of his smile.
If you're lookin for my pa, you're too late. He's over to Durant.
That's his bad luck then, ain't it. Here I come all this way to offer him a job.
What job?
He gestured toward the truckbed. Brought him a rooster.
A rooster ain't no job.
He shook his head sadly, grinning into his hat crown.
What all's he supposed to do with it then?
Hey, you remind me of someone, do you know that? Was you ever in the movin pictures?
Not hardly.
Then it was one of them photo magazines. Am I right?
She lowered her gaze, the heat prickling her face.
What's your name, anyways?
Lucile. Lottie to my friends.
His eyes left hers to scan the field behind her, settling on the spavined house and the broken windmill and the cold thread of woodsmoke hanging above them.
I got friends.
How old are you, anyways? Fourteen?
Thirteen.
Thirteen. He nodded once. I got me a niece name of Johnny Rae, and she's just about your age. She's my sister's youngest.
Lottie shaded her eyes. Does she live in these parts?
He nodded again. Matter of fact, she and me, we was gonna take us a drive down to Peerless tomorrow to visit my daddy. You ever been to Texas?
I don't know.
My daddy's got him a farm down there with cows and goats and pony horses. It's too bad you all couldn't come with us, cuz them horses need to get worked. He looked south, far beyond the horizon. Could use us another hand tomorrow, that's for damn sure.
She studied the stranger's profile. His tooled boots and his new Levi's and his polished oval belt buckle.
My pa wouldn't let me go noways.
How come? Why, you and me and Johnny Rae and her mama, we all could have us a day. Maybe eat us a picnic dinner. You like fried chicken?
I suppose.
And they's a swimmin hole for you girls if the weather holds. Hell, we all'd be back by sunset.
Well.
You want I should talk to your pa?
She shrugged. I don't know.
What's your pa's name, anyways?
Dillard Garrett.
Dillard Garrett, he said. As if weighing it.
They faced each other in the silence that followed, his corn- flower eyes locked on to hers. She looked away, fists thrust into pockets.
I got to go.
You need a ride somewheres?
No, sir.
Don't sir me. I ain't your daddy.
All right.
Clinton Palmer. That's my name. Clint to my friends.
Now you're funnin me.
Grinning again, he removed the matchstick and slid himself upright.
Tell you what. Come over here and take this rooster for your pa. I'll come by in the mornin, and him and me'll have us a little talk.
He climbed into the truckbed and, without bending, slid the lone crate toward the endgate with his boot.
Careful now. That's one rank bird.
The cock was rust over black, and the black of it held a greenish cast in the gridded sunlight. It fanned its ruff and pecked at the wire where she reached her hand.
Does he got a name?
No, ma'am, but I reckon you could give him one.
She tipped the crate carefully with her forearm, hiking it onto her hip. The bird was all but weightless, its pink talons balled and its pink head rooting in short and halting jerks.
He sure is fancy, but he don't weigh nothin a'tall.
She carried the crate across the ditch and hiked it again as she walked, pausing but once to turn and face the slender figure still skylighted in the truckbed.
I got me a notion to name him Clint.
The mill jobs in Durant had been but two jobs, for which over a hundred men had applied. Her father's voice quavered as he told the story, and between long tugs of bonded whiskey he cursed the day and he cursed the mill foreman and he cursed Mr. and Mrs. Roosevelt for good mea sure.
The rooster stirred in its cage.
It's got to where a white man can't find a honest day's work for a honest day's wages, he rasped, his hands trembling, his dark eyes shining in the firelight. It's got to where a Christian man is treated no better than a godless goddamn nigger.
Lottie listened, chewing and nodding in mute commiseration, waiting until at last her father had stoppered the bottle and rolled a smoke and leaned back into his bedroll. Only then did she broach the subject of Peerless, but his answer was curt, and emphatic, and so she let the matter drop.
The truck sat shimmering in the roadside sun as Lottie emerged barefoot from the creekbed. Before it were two figures in backlight, one tall and one short, the shape that was her father listening with folded arms while the smaller man spoke and gestured, first to the truck and then to the highway, and then in a sweeping arc that encompassed the broken house and the field where Lottie crouched in the pokeweed, her eyes closed, her lips moving in swift and silent prayer.
* * *
Where's Johnny Rae?
Lottie paused with her foot on the running board as Palmer held the door.
Packin her kit bag, I reckon. We'll fetch her up in Hugo.
He closed the door and circled the truck, clapping dust from his hands, his eyes scanning the highway in both directions.
The cab where she waited was spare and tidy and bore the masculine smells of motor oil and leather and old cigarettes. A spider crack stippled the corner of the windscreen. A cowhide valise, like a doctor's bag, rested on the seat beside her.
Palmer clambered in and slammed the door, setting his hat atop the valise and raking his hair with a hand. He looked at her and smiled. He turned the ignition and pressed the starter and mashed the pedals, working the shift lever up and back until the gears ground and caught and the truck lurched forward, rocking and wheeling southbound onto the empty highway.
That weren't too difficult.
What all'd you tell him?
Oh, let's see. That I was Clyde Barrow and needin me a gun moll, and that we all was gonna rob us some banks and shoot our way down to Mexico.
She giggled. You're crazy.
He said to bring him one of them sombrero hats is all.
The day was warm, and the warmth of it rippled on the scrolling blacktop. She watched him in stolen glances; the line of his nose and the set of his jaw and the dance of his hair in the breeze.
What is it?
Nothin, she replied.
You was smilin at somethin.
It weren't nothin to talk about.
They passed beanfields and cornfields and grazing cattle, and then the ironworks and the cotton compress, slowing only at the stockyard where the roadway and the rail line crossed. Palmer pointed out the railmen's barracks, and the ice plant, and a gated cemetery where he swore that elephants and circus clowns had been buried.
A redbrick bank was on the main street, and a general store, and they passed them both before turning left at midblock down a narrow alley.
(Continues...)
Excerpted from HARD TWISTEDby C. Joseph Greaves Copyright © 2012 by Charles J. Greaves. Excerpted by permission of BLOOMSBURY PRESS. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
Product details
- ASIN : B009K508OO
- Publisher : Bloomsbury USA; 1st edition (November 13, 2012)
- Publication date : November 13, 2012
- Language : English
- File size : 4.0 MB
- Text-to-Speech : Enabled
- Screen Reader : Supported
- Enhanced typesetting : Enabled
- X-Ray : Not Enabled
- Word Wise : Enabled
- Print length : 302 pages
- Best Sellers Rank: #2,872,327 in Kindle Store (See Top 100 in Kindle Store)
- #12,451 in Historical Literary Fiction
- #13,675 in Historical Mysteries (Kindle Store)
- #13,717 in Mystery, Thriller & Suspense Literary Fiction
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

C. Joseph Greaves spent 25 years as an L.A. trial lawyer before becoming a writer. He founded the Pasadena Public Library Foundation in 1982 while still in practice and served on its board of directors for over 20 years, including five as its president.
HARD TWISTED (Bloomsbury), his Dust Bowl-era literary debut, was called "a taut and intriguing thriller" (London Sunday Times) and "a gritty, gripping read, and one that begs to be put on film" (Los Angeles Times), and was a finalist for the Oklahoma Book Award in Fiction. The audiobook version of HARD TWISTED, wonderfully narrated by Meredith Mitchell, was selected by Booklist as one of its "Top Ten Crime Fiction Audiobooks of 2013."
TOM & LUCKY AND GEORGE & COKEY FLO (Bloomsbury), his second historical/true-crime novel of mobsters and madams, cops and lawyers in Depression-era New York, was named by the Wall Street Journal to its year-end list of the "Best Books of 2015," and was a finalist for, among other honors, the 2016 Harper Lee Prize for Legal Fiction.
His third novel, CHURCH OF THE GRAVEYARD SAINTS (Torrey House Press), is a story of home and family, love and loss set in the red-rock canyon country of an American Southwest under assault from oil & gas development. It's been called "one hell of a book" by LONGMIRE creator Craig Johnson, who describes Mr. Greaves as "one of my favorite authors." It was also selected by six U.S. cities to launch their "Four Corners/One Book" regional reading program for 2019-2020.
In addition to these stand-alone novels, Mr. Greaves writes award-winning mystery fiction as Chuck Greaves, including HUSH MONEY (2012), GREEN-EYED LADY (2013), THE LAST HEIR (2014), and THE CHIMERA CLUB (2022.) For more information, you can visit him at www.chuckgreaves.com.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book engaging, with one mentioning it kept them interested throughout. Moreover, the storytelling receives positive feedback, with customers noting it's based on a true story and one review highlighting how the author paints vivid landscapes in readers' minds. Additionally, customers appreciate the character development, with one noting how the characters come to life in the narrative.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
Customers find the book engaging, with one mentioning it kept them interested throughout, and another noting it's a fast and enjoyable read.
"...A highly recommended read and a stellar start for this new author! Five stars!" Read more
"...the historical information that he beautifully knit together for a good and informative read." Read more
"...I know I've read a great book when it sticks with me long after I have put it down. Such was the case with "Hard Twisted."" Read more
"...It is a fascinating story and worth the read...." Read more
Customers enjoy the storytelling of the book, finding it enthralling and compelling, with several noting it is based on a true story. One customer particularly appreciates how the author paints vivid landscapes in the reader's mind.
"...The author paints the landscapes in your mind and awakens your senses with his delightfully descriptive prose...." Read more
"This book was a little tough to read but fascinating...." Read more
"...and what I was seeing, smelling, and touching thanks to Greaves' lush imagery...." Read more
"C Joseph Greaves has woven a truly enthralling tale around the basis of a true story...." Read more
Customers appreciate the character development in the book, with one noting how the characters breathe and another mentioning how easy it is to know them.
"...His characters breathe; I wanted to take Lottie home with me, erase the memories of her bleak existence, and smother her with motherly love!..." Read more
"...I found it so easy to 'know' the characters, to imagine the history of those times and the hardships experienced...." Read more
"Loved this book and the characters. Greaves' paints pictures with his words as beautifully as the Creator painted the Southwest." Read more
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on December 11, 2012This novel sucks you in and takes you along for the ride as you follow Palmer and his young captive through the 1930s southwestern United States. The author paints the landscapes in your mind and awakens your senses with his delightfully descriptive prose. This story of betrayal, abduction and murder somehow allows you access into the mind of the victim and of the perpetrator where you find two desperate people seeking only to survive. A highly recommended read and a stellar start for this new author! Five stars!
- Reviewed in the United States on November 15, 2023This book was a little tough to read but fascinating. In reading the author’s notes, he ties together the historical information that he beautifully knit together for a good and informative read.
- Reviewed in the United States on November 21, 2012As I read this book I knew exactly where I was and what I was seeing, smelling, and touching thanks to Greaves' lush imagery. His characters breathe; I wanted to take Lottie home with me, erase the memories of her bleak existence, and smother her with motherly love! I know I've read a great book when it sticks with me long after I have put it down. Such was the case with "Hard Twisted."
- Reviewed in the United States on March 1, 2013C Joseph Greaves has woven a truly enthralling tale around the basis of a true story. I found it so easy to 'know' the characters, to imagine the history of those times and the hardships experienced. A great story, so mesmerising I just couldn't put it down.
- Reviewed in the United States on July 2, 2015At the beginning of the book, the relationship between the man & girl is somewhat implied. No gritty details or anything, which I liked. I also appreciated that there were only a few vignettes of the two together throughout the whole book. Toward the end the author gets a little more detailed, but I think he does so in order to get the reader on the side of the girl & to elicit a sense of disgust and finality from her. It is a fascinating story and worth the read. I found myself looking for more information about the case and the characters involved because there is so much going on before and after this story.
- Reviewed in the United States on March 28, 2013I'm sure Greaves is a grand fellow, but this book was terrible. Could not understand why the heroine was such a passive character, and you had 90% of the action occurring off-page, and then read where the story was based on an actual event. This is a case where not driving with a literary license was certainly a crime! Sorry, but a waste of time.
- Reviewed in the United States on March 25, 2013Our local book club selected this book in part because Mr. Greaves lives near us when I started reading I was impressed at the way the story was set up. The book kept me interested the whole way through at the end I was surprised to learn it was based on a true story. Good read!!
- Reviewed in the United States on November 3, 2013I am a descendant of Bill Oliver, and I must say that Mr. Greaves has done his research very well. I don't think he learned enough about the culture of southern Utah, as evidenced by the words he puts in Mr. Olivers mouth. I have spoken to several who knew him well and without exception they say "He would never have said that". All in all a good read and very well done for a novel that is based on a true story. By my assessment more true than novel!
Top reviews from other countries
- ConcreteovergroundReviewed in the United Kingdom on October 17, 2014
5.0 out of 5 stars Outstanding
I loved this book, from the moment I picked it up and began reading. Based on a true story, the author manages to capture the feel of the era, the way the people talk in that part of the world and the desolation of the geography.
While one has sympathy for Lucille, there cannot be many more hateful characters than Clint Palmer. The way the story and relationship between these two unfolds is story telling at its best.
A story that will endure in my mind for a considerable time.
- Mr. AC WrightReviewed in the United Kingdom on January 21, 2013
4.0 out of 5 stars Hard twisted
This is a book to get your teeth into -the West when cars were just coming in in a big way ,but horses were still the main transport . Hard ,uncompromising cruel but real and true to the life many people lived there .
- GlammananaReviewed in the United Kingdom on December 13, 2012
5.0 out of 5 stars Hard Twisted
This is a story that pulls you in and makes you care about Lucile as she traverses America with a killer and psychopath. She endures hard times which culminates in his trial for the murder of her father. Very well researched mixing fact and fiction.
- Tony BuckleyReviewed in the United Kingdom on January 7, 2013
2.0 out of 5 stars Rather a disappointment - certainly no "Grapes of Wrath"!
An apparent attempt to emulate Steinbeck's Grapes of Wrath; a rather dismal failure. The story is about a drifter who picks up a young girl and travels around in the depression always running from the law. While with her, she becomes pregnant, but loses the baby, and he keeps disappearing to get money. Various scams like cockfighting, betting on horses with the Navajo indians, looking after sheep. But meanwhile it seems he has murdered her father, whom she thinks they are looking for, and also some other people who got in his way - including two indians. Eventualy they are caught and she spends many months in jail as a material witness, he is convicted, and she sent to a child detention centre until she is 21. Written by a lawyer, who might have been interested in the true case on which it is based, but no real substance or content - unlike Grapes of Wrath (or even Suspicions of Mr Whicher or In Cold Blood)
- willowReviewed in the United Kingdom on December 19, 2012
5.0 out of 5 stars Hard Twisted
Hard times depicted with beautiful prose. Amazing story telling of true events. A gripping read, I didn't want the experience to end. Passed the book on to a friend, who was also impressed.